Deconstruction theory literary theory and criticism. The question of literature and why comic books deserve to be. The deconstructive technique is a vital part of postmodernism and can be seen in comic books and graphic novels like watchmen, v for vendetta, grant morrison s run on animal man or, to a lesser. Im not the first to mention grant morrison in this thread and i probably wont be the last. Way one perspective uc santa barbara, history department. Top 10 literary works in the comic book medium 10 mary jane spiderman loves mary jane by sean mckeever. People read comic books on the other hand to get away from learning and appreciating literature to escape to superheroes and supervillains, in the battle of good versus evil. Some of these are explained in more detail on the analysis tab. Deconstruction by nasrullah mambrol on march 22, 2016 6.
This means youre free to copy and share these comics but not to sell them. Aug 18, 2011 i dont appreciate dirty looks from literary elite when i tell them what i do for a living. In any case, a script of that comic book even one made sometime later would be literature, the same as a play. Find articles comics and graphic novels libguides at. Jimmy corrigan and the smartest deconstruction of the.
The character that began as a parody of comic book readers has been turned into a. You see, city of glass is a literary deconstruction though in less boring, english classy terms, it is an autopsy. If youre an english major student, then theres a likely chance that comics was brought up as an option for further study. All aspects and periods of english literature are covered, from anglosaxon times to the present day. You should comprehend that by literature, you seldom mean any longer much else besides a written piece of work. That is, comic books blend words and pictures so that, in addition to read ing text, readers see the characters through the il lustrations. The deconstruction of the superhero in watchmen grin.
It was originated by the philosopher jacques derrida 19302004, who. Deconstruction is also a certain thinking about tradition and context. The deconstruction of the superheroes and their dispensability. This might include the differences of watchmen to other superhero comic books. What is more, the interplay of the written and visual is a complicated process. And although some reasons for resisting that view are misguided, i shall argue that there are other good reasons for being hesitant about treating comics as a form of literature. Certainly a comic book is usually quicker to read, but depending on how its handled, things can. They are similar to modern day mythology, with fantastical settings and. Theyre art that blends delineation and text into a medium. Most of the other characters are captain ersatzes of other popular comic book archetype characters, with realistic human flaws added. Over the last thirty years, however, the industry has grown up and more and more books are written with adult readers in mind. In general, deconstruction is a philosophy of meaning.
As one might expect, this is a very broad term, with a number of different definitions in literary criticism, theoretical physics, and even plainold demolitions. In this sense, the comic is more like prose literature the reader can always go back and reread or skip ahead. With ebay, you dont have to choose sides, because we have plenty of any option. Beyond simply deconstructing batman though, the comic also. Hillis miller that made deconstruction a popular tool for the analysis of literature especially in us universities. Thomas 4 responses to comic books and deconstruction. Comics price guide was the first online price guide for comic books back in 1995. Even though classical literature and comic books differ in many ways, classical. While this framework will focus primarily on the metamorphosis of the novel into the comic book, the flexibility of the. Kind of have to disagree, while theres certainly some subtext youd be missing reading watchmen sans comic book knowledge its really not necessary. He reconstitutes a set of premises without which no deconstruction could have seen the light of day.
When it comes to comics, lets put literary criticism back on. Roy lichtenstein, the pop art icon, is a controversial subject in comic book circles for his appropriation of comic book panels originally created by legends such as jack kirby, john romita sr. That about sums up where comic book movies are at the moment. Top 10 literary works in the comic book medium listverse. Now, with the help of our expert panel, weve curated a list. Read more to find out how you can write your own comic book, with tips on everything from writing a comic book script, storyboard, inking, and more. Superheroes conquer the literary novel books the guardian. Deconstruction is an approach to understanding the relationship between text and meaning. Beginning in france in the 1950s, the structuralist movement in anthropology analyzed various cultural phenomena as general systems of signs and attempted to develop metalanguages of terms and. In the united states in the 1970s and 80s, deconstruction played a major role in the animation and transformation of literary studies by literary theory often referred to simply as theory, which was concerned with questions about the nature of language, the production of meaning, and the relationship between literature and the numerous discourses that structure human experience and its histories. Morrison has a lot to say about the creation of comics and the comic form in general in a lot of his works. Dcs new comic book distributors are midtown comics and dcbs dc comics russ burlingame 51 minutes ago dragon ball super spoilers tease moros edge over ultra instinct goku.
From journalism to literary fiction to canceled seasons of television shows, contemporary comic books can spotlight any subject. The premier online comics price guide free comic book values. Interestingly, the deconstruction for the most part comes only through the narration of the main characters, and the things that would happen off screen in comic books. It also tends to delve into moral ambiguity and sometimes straight up immorality and amorality. Aaron noble and the deconstruction of comic book art cbr. Apr 02, 2009 how comic books became part of the literary establishment tim martin shows that comic books are not just for nerds. The reader thus has a great deal of control over how they are viewed. How comic books became part of the literary establishment. This leaves us in an impasse we have reason both to classify comics as literature and to resist such classi. According to pulitzer they are, since a literary prize was awarded to the graphic novel maus.
In order to prove my thesis, i will first present a definition for stereotypical superheroes. Aug 22, 2014 gaiman in particular was marketed by vertigo, and by himself, as a novelist who just so happened to be working in the comic book field. Comic book artists have tools at their disposal, just as painters use. It was published by dc comics in 1986 and 1987, and collected in a single volume edition in 1987. Watchmen is an american comic book maxiseries by the british creative team of writer alan moore, artist dave gibbons and colorist john higgins. Graphic books offer a valuable lesson in story creation, literature studies, and even make for great tools in better understanding subject matter.
Unlike many other books that focus their analysis explicitly on the history of the comic book genre, the rise and reason of comics and graphic. Why comics have failed to achieve real respect sequart. Watchmen comic book literature, a true graphic novel. The titular character reads romance novels all the time, and comes to expect to live her own life that way, except her attitudes and behaviors destroy her life. This style of experimental literature emerged strongly in the united states in the 1960s through the writings of authors such as kurt vonnegut, thomas pynchon, and john barth. Classics illustrated is an american comic book magazine series featuring adaptations of literary classics such as les miserables, moby dick, hamlet, and the iliad.
He is an assistant professor of developmental english at norwalk community college in connecticut. Just as she hid the vegetables in her cake batter, i teach literary analysis through superhero comic books. List of books and articles about deconstruction online. Deconstruction of male duality in american comic books. I think most comics nowadays can qualify as literature. Subscribe to marvel unlimited to access thousands of digital comics for one low price. Deconstruction deconstruction deconstruction in literary studies. Many colleges have comic books in their libraries, but what you might not expect alongside the many literary classics at duke university is the mother lode of all comic book collections. Reconstruction builds them back up to be heroes again. Deconstruction can perhaps best be described as a theory of reading which aims to undermine the logic of opposition within texts. A survey of current scholarly indexes demonstrates that researchers in the fields of history, sociology, and literature are discovering that studying comic books provides unique and valuable insights on 20thcentury culture. The deconstruction of the superhero in watchmen the dispensability of superheroes taylor bruhn term paper advanced seminar didactics english literature, works publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. How did watchmen comic books deconstruct and parody the.
If youre into the darker side of religion and folklore, get this book. What is new is the larger embrace of comics as literature. The publication of the guide makes comic book collecting an accessible hobby to new fans and encourages market speculation possible outside of the comics community. But even if i didnt work in the industry, id still feel that way. Unfortunately a large segment of whats out there is. From our humble beginnings, we have grown to the largest, most complete comic book price guide with well over 1,000,000 comics in our database. For the past two decades, alan moore and dave gibbons watchmen has captivated comic book. Comic art, childrens literature, and the new comic studies. Most comic book lovers pledge allegiance to either dc comics featuring that famous alien from krypton and aquaman, among many othersor marvel comics, which gave us the webslinging spiderman, the new mutants and patriotic captain america. If any theory takes blood, sweat, and tears to master, its deconstruction. Comic books are more like movies in that one image follows another, though, unlike film, all the images are present simultaneously. Classical literature has an influence on the characters, types of different comic books, and. The edwin and terry murray comic book collection at the rubenstein library contains over 67,000 comic books donated as part of a comprehensive collection.
And yes i do believe that comic books are a viable form of literature. The comedian was a rapist and domestic abuser, his victim, silk spectre, although a superhero in her own right put up with his rape and abuse. Postmodern literature is a form of literature that is characterized by the use of metafiction, unreliable narration, selfreflexivity, intertextuality, and which often thematizes both historical and political issues. The development of a direct market of comic book shops, replacing newsstand distribution, also facilities the rise of comic book collecting as a hobby and potential investment.
Superlatives can sometimes be given carelessly, and can lose meaning. In short, he embodies every cliche about comics and was an embarrassment to those who advocated that comics deserved serious literary attention. Oct 15, 2012 this literary criticism is not fully developed. For decades the comic book industry, at least the mainstream comic book industry.
Watchmen made me fall in love with comic books not because of its deconstruction of tropes but because of. Often dismissed as white devil sophistry, this way of reading, pioneered by hottie jacques derrida, is one of the most rigorouser, hardcoreand useful around. When one thinks of the ultimate deconstruction of the superhero genre, however, there is one piece that lives up to that superlative. Mar, 2009 of course, noble isnt the first fine artist to use comic imagery in his work. We have values for any marvel, dc, image, idw, darkhorse, or dell comic book that is in your collection. With superhero comics and movies, deconstruction involves a cynical look at heroes, evaluating if theyd truly be good or evaluating the flaws in the comics. Thin periodicals called comic books appeared in the 1930s, at first reprinting newspaper comic strips. Comics and comic books are one of the most pervasive and influential media forms of 20thcentury popular culture. We see movies created and plays directed over and over again based on the same stories created hundreds of years ago. How comic books became part of the literary establishment tim martin shows that comic books are not just for nerds. The deconstruction of the superhero in watchmen publish. According to plenty of universities, they are, since there are literature courses taught about comics. The idea of using comic books as an educational tool isnt new, says michael bitz, founder of the comic book project at the columbia university school of education. Deconstruction distrusts the valorization of presence as the more authentic register of discourse i.
Superhero comics are most popular in the united states. Prose incarnations of the comicbook staples are not new, but. Deconstructions reception was coloured by its intellectual predecessors, most notably structuralism and new criticism. In the summer of 2005, writer kurt busiek and artist brent andersons comic book series astro city launched a new storyline, the dark age, promising a run of 16 issues divided into four 4. Selfrighteous rant aside, the problem im addressing is the latter. Comics in the classroom harvard graduate school of education. Because of the timeless nature of classic literature, it has a large influence in todays world.
There is the watchmen series for comic books, game of. To his own admission, this definition is rather awkward. The founder of deconstruction is jacques derrida explained as a strategy rules for reading, interpretation and writing. Comic art, childrens literature, and the new comics studies 361 in short, anxious talk about comic books for children has been in the air for years, in belated recognition of the way comic shops have generally excluded the young. Deconstruction deconstruction in literary studies britannica. It showed that superheroes were merely people with powers and the same flaws that most people have.
Comic books have long been written off by academics as junk literature best left to convention fanatics and hollywood directors, but some colleges have found that there is real value between the colorful pages of comic books and graphic novels. But today, comics are gaining respect in the educational community. Although most people think of superheroes when they think of comic books, there are several other genres for collectors to enjoy, including alternativeesoteric, manga, science fiction, fantasy, actionadventure, horror, humor, romance, childrens, and adult. This work is licensed under a creative commons attributionnoncommercial 2. Madame bovary is a fierce deconstruction of romance novels. Shadow mans book takes this and runs with it, showing him growing gradually more reckless and angsty as 1999 grows closer. This lesson introduces you to the terminology of comic books, also known as graphic novels. Deconstruction involves the close reading of texts in order to demonstrate that any given text has irreconcilably contradictory meanings, rather than being a unified, logical whole. For decades the comic book industry, at least the mainstream comic book industry, was targeted exclusively towards juveniles. Graphic novel, in american and british usage, a type of text combining words and imagesessentially a comic, although the term most commonly refers to a complete story presented as a book rather than a periodical. I think you bring up an important point, that deconstruction doesnt have to mean ugly and mean. A demonstration of the comic book mediums ability to not only. The success in 1938 of action comics and its lead hero superman marked the beginning of the golden age of comic books, in which the superhero genre was prominent. Deconstruction implies taking a stable archetype of something, for example a superhero like superman, and analyzing its basic components to turn it into something different.
The text has intertwined and contradictory discourses, gaps, and incoherencies, since language itself is unstable and arbitrary. The term deconstruction was coined by french philosopher jacques derrida in the 1960s. World comic book day had come and gone, which should concern you. And yet despite this difference of opinion, an important question is nonetheless raised amongst the literary community and that is. Coverage includes not only communication literature but also literature in other disciplines that is relevant to communication researchers, such as international literature in film studies, the role of technology in human communications, risk. Deconstructive criticism posits an undecidability of meaning for all texts. Again, theres an immediate conclusion that comic book fans and literature fans are from two entirely different worlds, unable to ever meet in the middle, see eyetoeye, or gasp actually be one. Jul 12, 2017 100 best comics and graphic novels we asked readers to name their favorite comics and graphic novels, and we got thousands of answers. Jacques derridas 1967 book of grammatology introduced the majority of ideas influential within deconstruction 25 derrida published a number of other works directly relevant to the concept of deconstruction.
Deconstruction without reference watchmen and evangelion. Created by albert kanter, the series began publication in 1941 and finished its first run in 1971, producing 169 issues. Local comic book shops are among the businesses that have had to adjust as city and state officials across the u. What are the best deconstructionist and reconstructionist. My book of lost doors series was a deliberate deconstruction of william. How to support local shops while comic book shipments are. Deconstruction in practice in deconstruction the signified and the signifier are unstable, and can take on multiple meanings. If youre into feminism, gender politics, and the deconstruction of gendered tropes, then by all means, get this book. Sep 18, 2015 it showed that superheroes were merely people with powers and the same flaws that most people have. Mark taylor evokes this with great clarity in the course of a remarkable introduction. While kingdom come was part of the mid90s wave of reconstructionist comics made in response to the abovementioned wave of deconstruction, its reconstruction of the silver age was accomplished by deconstructing the dark age, bringing it to its most extreme conclusion. Towards a theory of comic book adaptation unl digital commons.
Classic literature and comic books 83 words bartleby. Deconstruction literally means to take something apart. In constructing a deconstruction city of glass as the. Comic strips deserve to be taken seriously, as they can be rich in meaning, style, and structure. Literary text, like all texts, consist of a multiplicity of overlapping, conflicting meanings in dynamic, fluid relation to one another and to us.
1017 3 1505 1537 828 56 282 1129 446 288 1012 848 1301 581 220 153 392 1178 1264 726 626 821 802 831 357 1015 638 404 318 117 563 999 243 246 334 1446 949 581 331